Recent rumors swirling around Michael Phelps dating life have finally been addressed by the Alltime Olympian himself, sort of. In an interview with Extra, Phelps insisted he is not dating swimmer Amanda Beard. “I think she has a boyfriend,” he told interviewer Dayna Devon. Why didn’t you grill him about Lily Donaldson, Dayna?! Michael belongs to the public now, and we demand to know! An athlete dating another athlete is drab and unimaginative, but an athlete and a supermodel? Hysteria.